FAQ #191: Taking conventional financing

Question: I am currently operating a business and I would like to borrow funds from the bank to buy more inventory, is it halal for me to do so?

Answer:

Thank you for this question. The answer depends on what is meant by “borrowing from the bank.”

Buying more inventory and expanding a lawful business are themselves permissible. The Quran makes the basic distinction clear:

وأحل الله البيع وحرم الربا

“Allah has permitted trade and forbidden riba.”
(al-Baqarah 2:275)

The issue, therefore, is not the purpose of the financing, but the way in which the financing is structured.

If it is an interest-bearing loan

If the bank provides cash and requires repayment of the principal together with a predetermined amount of interest, the financing falls within the prohibition of riba.

This does not change merely because the money will be used for a lawful and productive purpose such as purchasing inventory. Classical jurists distinguished clearly between profit earned through trade and an increase stipulated upon a loan. Ibn Abd al-Barr summarised the principle:

كل زيادة من عين أو منفعة يشترطها المسلف على المستسلف فهي ربا، لا خلاف في ذلك

“Every increase, whether in property or benefit, which the lender stipulates upon the borrower is riba; there is no disagreement regarding this.”

For this reason, the prohibition is not limited to personal or consumption loans. A commercial loan does not become permissible simply because the borrowed money will be used to generate business income.

A sale is different from a loan

This should also be distinguished from genuine Shariah-compliant trade financing.

For example, in a proper murabahah arrangement, the financier purchases the required goods, becomes their owner and then sells them to the business at an agreed higher price payable later. The additional amount is the profit on a sale, rather than an increase charged on a cash loan.

This distinction reflects the Quranic principle itself: trade is permitted while riba is prohibited. What matters is not simply whether the customer ends up paying more over time, but what contract actually gives rise to that additional amount.

A useful legal maxim is:

العبرة في العقود للمقاصد والمعاني لا للألفاظ والمباني

“In contracts, consideration is given to their purposes and meanings, not merely their words and forms.”

A product therefore does not become permissible merely because it is labelled “financing” or uses the language of “profit” rather than “interest”. Conversely, not every arrangement involving deferred payment is riba. The actual contractual substance matters.

The Singapore context

There is also a genuine practical difficulty for Muslims operating businesses in Singapore. Unlike jurisdictions with a developed Islamic banking sector, Shariah-compliant financing options for businesses are very limited. Depending on the nature, size and circumstances of the business, there may in practice be no suitable Shariah-compliant financing alternative available.

That reality should be acknowledged. It is not practical simply to advise a Singaporean business owner to use Islamic financing when an appropriate product may not actually be accessible to the business.

However, the absence of an available Islamic financing product does not automatically make an interest-bearing loan permissible. Islamic law distinguishes between need and necessity.

A business may genuinely require additional capital, and the absence of financing may create real commercial difficulty. But this is not necessarily the same as a state of necessity that permits something otherwise prohibited.

The legal maxim states:

الضرورات تبيح المحظورات

“Necessities permit what would otherwise be prohibited.”

The threshold of necessity, however, is not reached merely because financing is unavailable, a business opportunity may be lost, growth will be slower, or the business cannot purchase as much inventory as desired.

Where the purpose of the financing is simply to increase stock, expand operations, improve profitability or take advantage of a commercial opportunity, this would ordinarily remain a commercial need, even where no Shariah-compliant bank financing is available.

What alternatives should be considered?

Even where Islamic bank financing is unavailable, the question is not limited to a choice between an Islamic bank and a conventional loan. Depending on the business, other possibilities may include negotiating deferred payment directly with suppliers, purchasing smaller quantities of stock, bringing in an investor or business partner, obtaining an interest-free private loan, restructuring existing obligations or postponing expansion.

These options may not always be commercially attractive or easy. But the fact that a permissible option is less convenient, more expensive or requires the business to grow more slowly does not by itself make an interest-bearing loan permissible.

In summary

If the bank financing is a conventional cash loan requiring repayment of the principal together with interest, the general ruling is that it is prohibited, even where the money is used to purchase halal inventory for a lawful business.

The limited availability of Shariah-compliant business financing in Singapore is a real difficulty and should not be ignored. Nevertheless, the absence of an Islamic financing alternative does not by itself amount to necessity.

Where the financing is merely for expansion, increasing inventory or improving profitability, an interest-bearing loan would generally remain impermissible.

And Allah knows best.

We are building a community!

And we want you to be part of it! Choose how you want to be notified: